Review: Sephora Cream Eyeliner Palette "Earthtones"

I picked up this palette because it was on sale on Sephora.com. I really wanted a bronze cream liner and I thought this palette had the perfect combination of colors. It was only $15USD.





The brush that came with it was beyond pathetic. See how tiny and minuscule it is? The brush tip was flimsy and small, it can't even draw a line. Trust me, I've tried. Right after taking this picture I gave it a nice home in my garbage can.





Here are the swatches with and without flash. Colors are pretty true and they are indeed very creamy.



However they were not smudgeproof at all, as you can see. In fact, it smudged pretty badly.



But it is waterproof though, as long as you don't rub it.



I think this would be better used as a cream shadow of some kind instead, I'm not sure how the smudge factor would affect my makeup though. I guess I'll just have to wait and see.